Long read incoming. I feel the criticism for his matchmaking has been taken a bit too far. He fought some decent guys before the Lima fight.
After the Lima fight he fought Kiely simply for the trash talk and kickboxer vs kickboxer style fight. Not great matchmaking by any means but I can see why Scott made that fight. MVP needed a highlight reel win to come back from the shadow realm.
After that he was booked to fight Derek Anderson who is a LW for the most part but one of the best Bellator fighters ever and he is now coming off a great WW win against 12-1 Mota. Instead he fought Melillo on very short notice.
The Anzai fight was also booked on very short notice to put MVP on the card. Anzai didnt deserve that MVP fight but Anzai is a much better opponent than someone like Melillo or Kiely. Anzai was Pancrase MW champ and was able to get multiple UFC wins.
Next he fought Ross Houston who was 8-0. In America maybe this fight wasnt ideal or big. It was more of a big deal in Europe. MVP was/is a star and Houston was a huge prospect and Cage Warriors WW champ. He was coming off that incredibly bloody fight against Dalby. In my opinion, this wasnt bad matchmaking. It was comain on the first card in France and quite a big deal in Europe.
All in all, I agree that there definitely couldve been better fights for MVP but he has fought some good guys and was willing to take short notice fights which we should appreciate. As far as I can tell there hasnt been any proof at all of MVP ducking any fights. Hes been calling for a Lima rematch for nearly 2 years now. He absolutely needs to fight someone like Larkin, Koreshkov or Homasi next.