I have been a Poirier fan since the fightville documentary which I believe aired in his WEC days, or right around his UFC debut. Love the dude, love his fight style, his attitude, the grace with which he has handled loss and victory...
But he was koed then fought a guy well outside the top 5. Also in principle it pisses me off that Gaethje is being passed over and punished for taking a big fight to help the company have a successful 300 instead of sitting on the sidelines which would have netted him a title shot. That sends the wrong message.
Lastly, Islam is not a busy fighter and I have little faith that he would turnaround in reasonable time should he and Gaethje win their respective fights.