I'm being hyperbolic, of course, but isn't that a crazy stat? I'll add Michael Johnson (3-6 since) and that means Gaethje's 6 UFC wins are a combined 6-22-1 after fighting him. So, were they truly top 10 caliber? Or were they cherry-picked, over-the-hill rank squatters? Rhetorical questions, just playing devil's advocate.
Similarly, his 4 losses have all been to undeniably great fighters in their primes but they also all finished him (and I just double-checked Sherdog PBP and confirmed he didn't win so much as one of the 10 rounds) so while there's not necessarily any shame in that, there's nothing particularly impressive about it either.
Not trying to hate on Justin (or pick a fight with you,) but I just noticed this now and I think it's really interesting.
You're being a bit harsh but only a bit, Tony was a huge win for Justin regardless of how Tony's career ended up going after. Tony was an elite LW for years but it is definitely possible Tony was beginning to slow down, he got rocked and dropped in many of his fights during his win streak (Lando, Pettis, Kevin Lee all dropped him that I can remember). To think at 36 and over 30 MMA fights that it might have been catching up to Tony for a while and Justin just exposed that to the world isn't unreasonable. I also have this belief that 155lbs was actually a pretty shallow division there for a while as so many guys began to age out of their primes but still remained in the top 10. Divisions go through culling processes and then periods of regrowth again, some eras are also simply better and worse than others.
Truly the rest of Gaethjes wins up until Chandler turned out to be crap, Barboza? Was definitely a chinny journey man who couldn't handle pressure. Vick? Was a very low level guy. Michael Johnson? Similar to Barboza, both talented but just inconsistent and incomplete journeymen types. Cerrone? Was well past his prime had been knocked out several times leading up to the Gaethje fight and had already turned into a journeyman himself. The Chandler win is more legit, I don't think that highly of Chandler and feel he's overranked due to having legit name value and an all American image but I still feel like Chandlers a dangerous fight for most top 10 guys, although I think I'd favor every single top 10 fighter over him if they fought.
Basically all of Gaethjes win have losing records in the UFC over the last 5 years, none of them aged well but it just doesn't matter because he became a title contender and a household name...He makes 500k show money and is a fan favorite, he will always get easier roads to and back to the title because of this and he will protect his standing because it's really all he's got, he's a brand more than a fighter these days. It just sucks because he's entitled and wants title shots handed to him without having to take fights or put win streaks together like the other guys.
And you're right, Dustin, Alvarez, Khabib and Oliveira handled him. Although I'd say his performances were respectable, he arguably deserved round 1 vs Khabib but Khabib was just there to gas Gaethje out who has trash endurance (so does Chandler), he hurt Oliveira and had his moments but definitely got outclassed there, his fights with Alvarez and Poirier were wars, Justin was clearly the lesser fighter but he hurt them and made it competitive somewhat too. Justin's formidable, he's just very flawed...bad cardio, sloppy striking, bad defense, horrible grappling, solid takedown defense it would appear. He hits hard, has great hand speed and kicks like a mule even from in close he's a God damn savage with loads of heart, an overachiever but he is flawed and hasn't ever improved much, a finished product that Tony fight was more of a false alarm.