He could have done great vs the right opponents, but it was never going to happen. Could even have been champ if he was matched up right. Rematch, catchweight vs Robbie would be fun.
1. He was a big star in kickboxing, and the UFC would force him to stop doing that.
Yeah, I was also thinking that his schedule of MMA and Kickboxing bouts being intertwined like that, sounds a bit like Fedor and his passion for Sambo combat.
One of the reasons he gave for not signing with the UFC was that he could not keep on competiting every year in the sambo world championship...
Manhoef would have been screwed, since the Netherlands have a big kickboxing scene and he's a star there. But they also don't have a lot of elite BJJ black belts, which explains his bad sub defense.
In the UFC, I think he would have done like he did outside. Several highlight worthy first round KOs, but also several submission losses and a couple brutal KO's, and would be released after too many...
I really liked Manhoef back in the days, well the Saku fight broke my heart but aside from that dude was brutal.
One of the very rare non-heavyweight who has that "can KO you at any time" factor. Plus, his cool shorts would look awesome from the top view during his hooks and kicks...
He had such a mean hook à la Deontay Wilder, I wish he could have gotten 2 or 3 fights in the UFC at least.