- Joined
- Oct 24, 2003
- Messages
- 21,732
- Reaction score
- 2,611
And who created the ghettos? Are you aware that redlining still exists to this very day?
And how do people get out of ghettos, or generally escape poverty?
History tells us that the American middle class was built on two things - the ability to acquire loans, and government assistance like the GI Bill after WW2. These two things created the largest explosion of the middle class in the history of the world. And it's easy to see why. Joe Schmoe owns nothing, then gets a home loan or small business loan, and now all of a sudden he has assets which in turn creates generational wealth in families. It's probably the reason you most likely grew up in a middle class home, went to a decent public school, enjoyed decent healthcare.
African Americans were left out of that entire equation. The few who did manage to secure some assets, such as homes, were restricted to areas where their homes did not appreciate nearly as much as everyone else's.
So the government herded blacks into the worst areas of town, where they did not enjoy the same opportunities as whites, and therefore were always living under the thumb of a landlord and spending their money in white owned businesses because up until recently, it was near impossible for African Americans to secure small business loans and therefore improve their own communities. Also, given schools are funded by property taxes, their schools suffered more, as well as their access to healthcare.
Now, have things gotten much better? Absolutely. But acting as if none of this happened, or that it is so far removed in the past that it doesn't matter, only potentiates the divide between races. Blacks are bitter because they've traditionally got the raw end of the stick - always paying a white slumlord, only seeing businesses in their neighborhoods operated by anyone but African Americans. They did not enjoy the same opportunities that whites were using to build that generational wealth. That doesn't mean your average middle class white guy is responsible, on the contrary, whites used those opportunities to their benefit and built something that the rest of the world envies. No shame in that whatsoever.
However, ignoring a lot of the variables and dynamics that actually built the ghettos is short-sighted. Snapping your fingers and saying "black people have equal opportunity with whites now' doesn't wash away the fact that whites have had 2 or 3 generations of owning small businesses, farms, family homes, educational loans, etc to build what are great communities today.
Yes, African Americans have it much better today than 70 years ago. But 70 years is not that long of a time when you are talking about uplifting lower class communities into middle class communities, and it's very easy to understand that desperation breeds crime and a vicious cycle that is difficult to escape, hence ghettos, and the snowball effect of never actually being able to own anything, or pass anything down to your children. Even if the majority of whites are not recipients of this generational wealth, they still benefited from the middle class schools, healthcare, and a variety of opportunities that make even securing a loan much more viable.
This is not to say that what Coke is doing is the answer - far from it, I don't agree with attempting to elevate one group at the expense of another - that would simply be repeating the same mistakes. I don't pretend to have all the answers, but going to the other extreme, by ignoring how our middle class was actually built and who exactly were the beneficiaries of that, is not the answer either. Not saying you are specifically, but it is quite common.
Excellent post.