Jon Jones looks infinitely better not only because his accomplishments make Islams look tiny comparatively…….. but because his loss to Hamill looks infinitely better than being KO’ed and ACTUALLY losing. His lackluster performance against Reyes (where he looked stronger as the fight went on) still has better optics imo than having someone beating the piss out of you in the final round (where you look like you would lose if you had to keep fighting) in a fight you were suppose to dominate as you panic watch the clock…….. nothing Islam has ever done comes close to Jon dusting Gane for a title.
This being said I think Islam has a great chance to become the GOAT LW with 2 key metrics (win streak and title defenses). I don’t see him coming remotely close to DJ, GSP, JBJ etc. his fight frequency won’t allow it and he will likely either leave to avoid new blood or lose.