- Joined
- Feb 28, 2023
- Messages
- 7,762
- Reaction score
- 14,837
It’s a tough argument being that he got steamrolled by max twice and lost to Volk as well. That being said, he DOES get the longevity vote. Truly a hard question to answer.
It's not really a tough argument. Silva lost twice to Weidman, that doesn't put Weidman over him. Edgar isn't a greater LW than BJ. Almost all championship runs come to an end via losses. If Topuria knocks out Volk again in a rematch it isn't going to make him GOAT. He still needs to accomplish what the guys before him did.
IMO Volk had a chance to surpass Aldo but he fucked around at 155 and got two losses instead.