- Joined
- Apr 23, 2020
- Messages
- 3,901
- Reaction score
- 17,062
It's pointless to argue about which one is better. It's all based on preference.Mafia 2 wasnt a remake but a remaster....thats why it looks the same as the original.
Mafia 2 has a much better plot, characters and is generally better everywhere.
Its not GTA, and I never expected it to be. Both the games can be cut in half and you wouldnt miss anything in terms of the plot, you'd cut out the boring location to location driving, the inane wave by wave enemies, etc.
Mafia 1 is mediocre, and 2 is good only because of everything but the gameplay.
If Mafia 2 had a complete remake maybe I would have prefered that one. But based on Mafia and Mafia 2 definitive edition. I have to go with the first one.
The games definitely have their flaws but I think 6.5 is a bit harsh for such a great game.