RDR2 is awesome. Don't think anyone reasonable would find issue with you there, friend.
@SaiWa Do you like Super Punch Out and Wii's Punch Out? I find myself going back to the Wii one over and over.
Another game I keep coming back to is Final Fantasy IX. Very well done equipment/ability system, lots of fun side quests and hidden things, and there's a new mod that completely overhauls the visuals. And I mean everything-- not just higher polycount and more faithful design of models, but they recreated all the assets for the prerendered backgrounds. Each "map" has been completely redone.